In early 20th century New York City, female criminality was largely driven by socioeconomic survival, systemic discrimination, and restricted labor options, presenting a stark contrast to the sensationalized “bad girl” archetypes found in the yellow journalism of the era.

While the public was captivated by tales of glamorous confidence women and ruthless madams, municipal data and historical records from the NYC Department of Records & Information Services reveal that most women entering the justice system were low-income, immigrant, or Black women struggling against structural poverty.

The economic landscape of the Progressive Era and the Prohibition era heavily dictated the types of offenses women committed. The most frequent offenses were shoplifting, pocket-picking, and petty larceny. For many, especially Black women excluded from formal job markets, theft functioned as a tactical economic response to systemic “steal or starve” conditions.

Brothels and street-level prostitution were heavily criminalized. Brothel operators were formally charged with keeping a “disorderly house. The “badger game” and grifting popular extortion con involved a woman ("the badger") luring a wealthy man into a compromising position, only for her male accomplice to burst in, threaten exposure, and blackmail the victim.

With abortion strictly outlawed by state statutes, a network of female midwives and back-alley practitioners faced severe homicide or conspiracy charges for providing reproductive healthcare. During the Prohibition era of the 1920s, some women carved out highly lucrative paths as speakeasy operators, alcohol smugglers, and illegal lottery managers.

Here are some mugshots of female criminals in New York City in the early 20th century:

Sadie Schoen, June 25, 1908. Crime: Swindling.

Fannie Ecoff, January 7, 1908. Crime: Fagin.

Lillie Bates, June 17, 1909. Crime: Badger.

Maggie Moore, August 26, 1910. Crime: Malicious Mischief.

Esther Ginsberg, June 1, 1910. Crime: Disorderly House.

Catherine Brenzel, March 13, 1914. Crime: Rape.

Isabella Ziegler, Grand Larceny. Photographed upon release from Bedford Hills Correctional Facility for Women, July 6, 1920.

Vintageeveryday

Message History

Delivery option(s)