The Road to the Kentucky Derby is essentially complete.

Yes, technically one minor prep remains—the Lexington Stakes—but it carries no real Kentucky Derby implications. The field is set. The contenders are locked in.

With all major prep races in the books, it’s time for our FINAL Top 10 Rankings before we shift gears to full-on Derby picks. These rankings combine each voter’s evaluation of what the horses have done so far and their chances to win on the first Saturday in May.

And as always, these rankings combine input from myself, Aaron Halterman, and Hall of Fame handicapper Jon White, all of whom are official voters in the NTRA Top 3-Year-Old Poll.

Let’s dive in

1. Further Ado

(Jared Rank: 2 | Aaron Rank: 1 | Jon Rank: 1)
If you want the most likely winner, it’s probably Further Ado.

That Blue Grass win was a statement—106 Beyer, visually dominant, and peaking at the exact right time. You don’t see performances like that this late in the prep season very often.

The only reason I don’t have him #1 is because I still slightly lean toward Renegade’s overall consistency—but make no mistake, this horse is the one everyone has to beat.

2. Renegade

(Jared Rank: 1 | Aaron Rank: 2 | Jon Rank: 2)
I’m sticking with Renegade at #1.

This horse has done nothing wrong from the jump—consistent, professional, and continues to look like a horse that’s built for the grind of the Derby. He doesn’t need everything to go perfectly to fire, and that matters a lot in a 20-horse field.

He may not have the flashy number that Further Ado just threw down, but from a total body of work + reliability standpoint, this is still my top horse heading into Churchill for now.

3. Commandment

(Jared Rank: 3 | Aaron Rank: 3 | Jon Rank: 3)
You want a horse that shows up every single time? This is your guy.

Commandment just keeps firing. No excuses, no bad efforts, no drama. He’s tactical, he’s professional, and he fits just about any race shape you throw at him.

He may not have had that “wow” breakout race, but he’s sitting on a race that could absolutely win the Derby.

4. The Puma

(Jared Rank: 4 | Aaron Rank: 4 | Jon Rank: 5)
The Puma is one of the more intriguing horses in this group.

There’s still a little bit of “is he really good enough?” here—but the upside is real. When he’s right, he looks like a legitimate top-tier horse.

If he takes even a small step forward on Derby Day, he’s right there with the top three.

5. Emerging Market

(Jared Rank: 6 | Aaron Rank: 6 | Jon Rank: 4)
This is your classic late-developing horse.

Emerging Market keeps getting better, and I think Jon’s higher ranking reflects that upside. The question is whether he’s ready to put it all together against the best of this group.

If he takes another step forward, he’s dangerous. But asking a horse to win the Derby in just his third start is a big ask.

6. Chief Wallabee

(Jared Rank: 5 | Aaron Rank: 5 | Jon Rank: NR)
I’m keeping Chief Wallabee higher than Jon, and I’m comfortable with it.

This horse has quietly put together a really solid campaign. He’s tough, consistent, and doesn’t seem to get rattled by much. Not flashy, but very usable—especially underneath in exotics.

He’s the type that can absolutely clunk up for a big piece at a price. He could even win. But his immaturity could also be his biggest issue on Derby Day.

7. Silent Tactic

(Jared Rank: 8 | Aaron Rank: 7 | Jon Rank: 8)
Silent Tactic is just… solid.

He’s not going to wow you on paper, but he keeps showing up and running competitive races. In a race like the Derby, that kind of consistency can go a long way.

Feels like more of a “hit the board” type than a win candidate—but that still has value.

8. Fulleffort

(Jared Rank: 9 | Aaron Rank: 8 | Jon Rank: 9)
You know exactly what you’re getting with Fulleffort.

He tries every single time and has proven he belongs with this group. The question is whether he has another gear—and I’m not totally convinced he does.

Still, he’s the type that can hang around and make things interesting late.

9. So Happy

(Jared Rank: 10 | Aaron Rank: 9 | Jon Rank: 6)
This is where things get interesting.

Jon is clearly higher on So Happy than the rest of us, and I can see the case. There’s some sneaky upside here, especially if the pace sets up right. He certainly looked awesome in the Santa Anita Derby (G1)!

For me, he’s more of a fringe contender—but definitely not one I’m completely dismissing.

10. Class President

(Jared Rank: 7 | Aaron Rank: NR | Jon Rank: NR)
This is probably my most controversial ranking—and I get it.

But I’m not ready to completely toss Class President. The talent is there, no question. The concern is the lack of recent racing and that he could actually be injured.

Best-case scenario, everything clicks and he outruns expectations. Worst case, he’s simply not seasoned enough for this kind of test. Or worse, he misses the Derby completely.

Just Missed

Incredibolt (Aaron #10)
Denon Bourbon (Jon #7)
Pavlovian (Jon #10)

A few interesting names here, but ultimately just not enough to crack my Top 10 heading into the big one.

Final Thoughts

This is it.

No more prep races. No more guesswork on form cycles.

Now it’s all about trip, pace, and execution on Derby Day.

Further Ado may be the current king, but as we know, the Kentucky Derby has a way of flipping the script when it matters most.

Next stop: official picks, betting strategies, and the BIGGEST Betting Bible of the year.

The New Betting Bible Has Arrived

The New & Improved Betting Bible delivers race analysis, pace projections, AI picks, expert selections, and fast race updates and scratches — all redesigned for race-day speed.

Racing Dudes

Message History

Delivery option(s)