Fifteen minutes and a flop

In 2025 Dwayne Johnson walked into the Venice Film Festival as a fighter called Mark Kerr, hidden under prosthetics, quiet and scared, and the room stood and applauded for fifteen minutes. A month later The Smashing Machine opened to the weakest box office of his career. Both facts are true, and together they explain Johnson better than his entire filmography does.

For twenty years the question around him has been about leverage. The most powerful man in the business, with the best deal-making instincts in Hollywood: can he still open a film? I think that is the wrong question. The right one is simpler. What does an audience actually pay to see? My answer is the one trick he has run since the start: bravado with a scar. Take away either half and the tickets stop.

The wrestler who learned to wink

Johnson didn’t arrive as an actor. He arrived as The Rock, a wrestling character built on an eyebrow, a catchphrase and a sense of timing most leading men never learn. The Scorpion King (2002) turned that into a movie career, a sword-and-sandals spin-off from The Mummy Returns that handed him a lead role at an age when most wrestlers are still waiting to be taken seriously. Walking Tall (2004), a remake of a 1973 vengeance picture, kept him in the same lane: a huge man coming home to a town that wronged him.

Look at what those roles share. Both heroes are the strongest man in the room, and both carry a grievance. The first thing audiences bought was not his size. It was the wound that came with it.

Hobbs: the best thing he ever rented

Fast Five (2011) is where the legend begins. Agent Luke Hobbs arrived as a federal hunter chasing Vin Diesel’s crew, and Johnson did something rare: he gave a franchise a second engine. The series moved from street racing to heists and blockbusters, and the audience cheered that Hobbs and Dom bumped heads, because for once the muscle had competition.

Hobbs & Shaw (2019) was the proof. A spin-off built around him and Jason Statham, two men bickering like their pride was the only thing neither could lift, grossed north of $750 million worldwide. That’s the template: swagger up front, wounded ego underneath, and a partner who knows exactly where to poke.

Still, notice the key word. Hobbs was rented. The franchise belonged to someone else. It was Johnson’s best deal, and also the one that taught Hollywood to keep him inside someone else’s house.

Ballers and Young Rock: the part nobody counts

The credits people forget are the ones I rate highest. Ballers (HBO, 2015 to 2019) ran five seasons, with Johnson as Spencer Strasmore, a former NFL player who retired with a wrecked body, a shaky bank balance and a loud need to be somebody again. It is the swagger-with-a-bruise formula in its purest form, in a show he helped produce and could shape.

Young Rock (NBC, 2021 to 2023) went further and turned his own life into a sitcom, framed by his mock campaign to run for president in 2032. It was a joke, but a smart one. For the first time he was selling the story of how a kid whose family moved constantly and sometimes ran out of money became The Rock. That’s the bruise before the swagger.

No cape. No franchise to rent. Just a charming man telling you what it cost. Ballers is, to me, the clearest proof of what he does best, and of why Hollywood keeps trying to talk him out of it.

Old brands, no bruise

Then came the revivals. G.I. Joe: Retaliation (2013) made him Roadblock, a toy-line soldier. Baywatch (2017) put him in a lifeguard’s red shorts in a nostalgia comedy that critics buried and audiences shrugged at.

Both films wanted his name and not his wound. He played the shiniest, most capable man in the room and nothing ever touched him. The old brands didn’t need him, and the movies had no idea what to do with the part of him people actually like.

Black Adam: the bet that cost him

The big gamble came next, and it was personal. Johnson fought for years to bring Black Adam to the screen, and he promised, with the confidence only a man with his leverage can afford, that the balance of power at DC was about to change. When Black Adam arrived in 2022 it grossed about $390 million worldwide, against a budget that left it a disappointment, and the sequel talk died.

The reason is in the character. Black Adam is a god who is humorless and mourning, who never flinches and has no joke. That is a man with no swagger and no bruise, only rage. It took the one thing audiences like about Johnson and replaced it with scowling. He was no longer a charming man who occasionally gets hurt. He was a statue with a cape.

Netflix and the Christmas gamble

Red Notice (2021) took him to Netflix, with Ryan Reynolds and Gal Gadot, and the streaming numbers were huge. It made money for the platform and proved nothing at the box office, because nobody paid for a ticket. Red One (2024), a Christmas action comedy with Chris Evans, was the theatrical gamble that tried to prove the opposite. With a budget around $250 million, it earned far less than it cost.

Streaming gave him audiences. Theaters demanded a draw. Those are not the same thing.

The Smashing Machine

Which brings us back to Venice. In The Smashing Machine (2025), director Benny Safdie, who won the Silver Lion for the film, cast Johnson as Mark Kerr, a pioneering UFC fighter wrestling with addiction and a destructive relationship. It was the bruise with no swagger around it. Critics were kind to the performance. Audiences, who had come for the other half, stayed home: roughly $20 million worldwide and the weakest opening of his career.

I don’t read this as a failure of ambition. It was the right dare and the right test. It showed that the formula needs both halves, and that when you take the swagger away, you ask the audience to pay for pain alone.

The safe harbor

Now he is in the family business. Moana 2 (2024) crossed a billion dollars. The live-action Moana arrived in July 2026 to a softer response than Disney wanted, and Jumanji: Open World is due in December. People call this a retreat. I’d say it’s the one place the formula is allowed to run in full. Maui is its purest version: a demigod who is vain, funny and secretly terrified that without his hook he is nothing.

The verdict

Look at the three roles Johnson fans actually love: the Scorpion King, Hobbs and Spencer Strasmore. Three different genres, one trick. Swagger up front, bruise behind it, and a script that lets him laugh at both.

Every miss since is a role that asked him to drop one half. The Rock never ran out of draw. He kept betting it on parts that took the wound away.

Budomate

Message History

Delivery option(s)